Introduction
Napoleon was one of the greatest leaders of all time. In the course of his life, he rose from a humble background to become a great French military leader, leader of France and, eventually, master of most of Europe. There were those who loved him, as well as those who hated him.
Claim
Ultimately, Napoleon was both a child of the Revolution, and a tyrant.
Clarification
By child of the Revolution, it is meant that someone who was influenced by, and tried to put in place, the ideas and values of the French Revolution such as equality, freedom, and opportunity. By tyrant, it refers to a leader who abuses his or her power.
Evidence #1
One way in which Napoleon might be seen as a child of the revolution is through the fact that he tried to establish a society in which people were promoted in jobs by merit, rather than by birth.
Warrant #1
By doing so, Napoleon was showing his belief in the revolutionary ideal that all should have equal opportunity, and that just because someone was born a noble they should not be given certain privileges, and vice versa. Just as Napoleon rose from relatively small beginnings, he wanted others to be able to do the same.
Evidence #2
It is also important to point out that Napoleon promoted the idea of religious toleration in France as well as the other countries he conquered.
Warrant #2
By promoting religious toleration, again, Napoleon was supporting the ideals of the French Revolution by showing his belief in individual freedom, liberty and openness. He did not think that the government should be controlled by the church, or that the government should require people to follow one religion over another.
Evidence #3
On the other hand, Napoleon crowned himself dictator and tried to centralize all political power in his own government.
Warrant #3
By doing so, Napoleon was showing himself as something of a tyrant, taking power from the people, ruling as a dictator, and maintaining a government, controlled by himself, that held all important political power in France. It was very far from the idea of republic many of the revolutionaries wanted in which the people would have more power.
Conclusion
In the end, Napoleon was a complex figure who remains something of an enigma.
No comments:
Post a Comment